Skip to content
Monday, November 9, 2026
Next Club Studio

A Proposal to Reform the Academy System and Support Young Players

A standout among my most memorable instances during the football year occurred the other day, observing a homegrown player charge up the pitch from his defensive penalty area to score a clinching finish.

Local talents are consistently celebrated by their club's supporters and, based on my observations, the faithful are likely to experience many more exceptional performances from him in the time to come.

Yet, for a single player who makes it, there are countless of other youngsters who fail to progress beyond the myriad levels, and have to face a devastating setback at a formative age.

It is these players who drop out of academy football that are my focus, because I feel the current system is sufficient to advise them about their odds, or look after them when they are let go.

It demands an reform and, when I stepped away, I put together my own study into the academy system, featuring proposals for how it could be improved.

An Massive Commitment – With Some Major Rewards

My outlook on youth setups is not just as a former coach. My grandchildren are in the programme, so I've got a personal stake too.

For all young footballers, the dream of becoming a pro player is a unique one. The academy system has been put in place to give them the greatest chance to achieve that ambition, with a dedicated plan being launched over a decade ago.

Right now, over twelve thousand of boys are in the system, at clubs from the highest division down. It's an demanding structure, with training at least three evenings a week and a fixtures programme that occupies most of their weekends.

The equivalent programme is now being adopted by the rapidly expanding sport, women's football, too.

These setups are manned at extraordinary levels and create work for trainers, physiotherapists, medical staff and many more support staff.

The facilities are of the best standard, with top-class indoor and outdoor pitches. Academic study is offered too, with teachers employed to run required vocational programmes.

The outlay is enormous but, as we have witnessed, the teams at the top end are reaping significant returns on that investment through loans and sales of the academy-produced players.

What is the status of the Current Framework?

The key development plan has been in operation for almost 15 years now, so how has it performed to the test of time?

Academies now operate a pre-academy programme for children from the age of six, so if any of them complete the entire programme they would complete at 21. That's longer than a child spends in mainstream school, and spans his whole childhood.

These children are issued with team tracksuits and coats, all emblazoned up, and are recognised by peers and family as being associated with that club.

Their sense of self has, practically, been imprinted on them at a tender age and they also have to make a total commitment to the academy regime.

That means training on three nights a week, and a fixtures programme taking up most of the weekend, are now integral to a youngster's journey to follow his dream.

From my experiences, in a lot of cases what happens at their studies is seen as being less important, with the academy taking over and turning into the main concern of the child and his parents' life.

A number of families see a financial reward at the end of the path if their child succeeds and put tremendous stress on their shoulders to succeed.

Unfortunately, figures show the system has a complete mismatch of achievement and failure. We all see the ones who make it, but we rarely see those who don't succeed.

Be Realistic About Their Chances

I have no desire to remove those hopes away from young players but we need to be honest with them about their chances.

While there are specific individuals a club will identify as being potential professionals, the fact is a significant proportion of the youngsters have only been on the programme to fill the spots needed for practice and the weekend games at each age group.

I genuinely think academies adequately set the understandings of these players or parents, about where they sit in the broader process.

Players and parents need to be given a full assessment of where they stand, so they can plan for the probable setback when it arrives.

Our academies have developed some outstanding talent and there is greater consideration paid to player care now than in the past, but let's also incorporate a bit more priority on transparency too.

More Priority on Academics

As I stated above, I believe many youth players joining academies actually take more notice of their coaches at times than they do of their schoolteachers.

It's vital this is recognised within the academy system, and youth directors communicate this directive to the coaches at all age group.

This phenomenon itself is nothing new. Mentoring played a massive part in my development, and sports teachers and coaches were always held in immense regard.

But, for anyone running an academy, they must ensure the coaches are given explicit direction and understanding of their role because of the sway they have.

Standards of respect, conduct and hard work should be as stringent as they are in any educational environment – and should apply to the academic side of the child's life there too.

The framework I have suggested would have increased weight on academics and counselling – for families as well as the youth players – and also planning for what comes next if they are let go aged 16.

My Proposal to Assist Youth Players

I would place academies within six zones, each managed by a head and link them with partner schools and colleges.

Before they get to scholarship level, players would be evaluated at 14 to see what academic route is appropriate for them.

At 16, players starting apprenticeships would begin in a compulsory integrated academic programme with the academic partners.

Concurrently, the players who are let go at 16, can start a dedicated combined academic programme with the schools or colleges.

The benefit for them would be the creation of a independent competitive programme where the schools and colleges would

By

Joe Smith

A digital artist and innovation strategist with over a decade of experience in creative technology and design thinking.

Next Club Studio

Type to search articles.